Drop Score 0–100 · synthesized from independent reviews — it measures quality, not price.
Saucony Guide 19 review: what runners say
Fit
Wide and accommodating fit, with a tall, roomy toe box. Adaptive engineered mesh: runners with medium or slightly wide feet find a good match staying with their usual size.
Feel
Generous cushioning with a wide base and sidewalls that cradle the foot; the updated PWRRUN is softer but returns little energy. Some sources note a feeling of heaviness and lack of responsiveness during runs.
Durability
XT900 rubber coverage extended across the full outsole: consensus across sources indicates an improvement over the Guide 18. Expected mileage not quantified, but the thick outsole is considered a strong point.
Best for
Easy running and slow paces, active recovery, daily training use. Suited to runners seeking mild stability in a max-cushion profile; also appreciated as a walking shoe.
Weak points
The added weight compared to the Guide 18 is the most recurring criticism. Multiple sources agree on poor responsiveness: the softer foam is a drawback for runners looking to pick up the pace. Missing pull tab noted as a regression.
We read and watched 6 sources for you· 4 video · 2 articles